Труха⚡️Україна
Труха⚡️Україна
Қарау
Николаевский Ванёк
Николаевский Ванёк
Қарау
Реальна Війна | Україна | Новини
Реальна Війна | Україна | Новини
Қарау
Труха⚡️Україна
Труха⚡️Україна
Қарау
Николаевский Ванёк
Николаевский Ванёк
Қарау
Реальна Війна | Україна | Новини
Реальна Війна | Україна | Новини
Қарау
German Aid to Ukraine avatar

German Aid to Ukraine

Tracking Germany's aid | Plenty of writing | Proud to be mentioned on German television
Enquiries: info@deaidua.org
Support: https://ko-fi.com/deaidua
TGlist рейтингі
0
0
ТүріҚоғамдық
Растау
Расталмаған
Сенімділік
Сенімсіз
Орналасқан жері
ТілБасқа
Канал құрылған күніЛип 02, 2023
TGlist-ке қосылған күні
Жовт 11, 2024
Мен каналдың иесімін
Өзгерістер тарихы
Қосылған топ
German Aid to Ukraine Chat
German Aid to Ukraine Chat
3

Рекордтар

18.05.202514:17
195Жазылушылар
05.05.202513:35
1400Дәйексөз индексі
11.02.202523:24
3.3K1 жазбаның қамтуы
30.03.202514:52
43Жарнамалық жазбаның қамтуы
13.05.202500:33
53.33%ER
18.01.202523:24
2117.53%ERR

Өсу

Толығырақ
Жазылушылар
Цитата индексі
1 хабарламаның қаралымы
Жарнамалық хабарлама қаралымы
ER
ERR
СІЧ '25КВІТ '25
Толығырақ

German Aid to Ukraine танымал жазбалары

Барлық жазбалар
11.05.202509:17
Another point. Will Merz keep his word? No idea! For years, Friedrich Merz and the CDU have criticised the previous government for not providing enough military aid, and rightly so in some cases. Now that he is in power and no longer provides information about military aid, it will no longer really be possible to verify whether he is actually doing more than Scholz, or whether it was and is all PR fog and propaganda for the election campaign.

In principle, as it is the case in France, he could keep making magnificent statements, but in reality he could reduce military aid and nobody would notice unless the Ukrainian government talks about it (which they won't), or it gets leaked to the media.

I see this as a massive problem, especially given the recent statement of the new Foreign Minister, who said on TV that the new German government will not do more in terms of military aid than the former German government.

One last point. Fake news and propaganda. When the new government doesn't disclose its military aid in rough numbers anymore, we can't combat (pro-Russian) propaganda (also in Germany) anymore.

How on earth should we now prove that Germany is actually doing something for Ukraine, or that we have provided Ukraine with close to €48 billion in assistance and not the €200 billion some East German Putin fan claims when he talks about how damaged our economy and country is, but we are spending hundreds of billions on an already lost war. You get what I mean.

Thanks to anyone who has actually read that far. I apologize for the long text guys, but I feel like 90% of all people have an entirely wrong impression of transparency and what the changes mean for Germany and Ukraine.

~ GAU
11.05.202509:17
It looks like I need to clear up a few false assumptions that have developed in connection with the decision to not disclose Germany's military aid to Ukraine in the future anymore.

1) That means the Taurus is coming!
Wrong. This decision has nothing to do with Taurus. I know numerous examples in which the former government has either financed or already delivered equipment that was never made public (for example, at the request of the end customer in Ukraine) or assistance was at least announced but never included in the official list of the federal government.

The new government under Merz could have handled a Taurus delivery in exactly the same way — without any problems. Simply not announce it and that's that.

You don't have to reduce transparency to zero in order to hide a delivery. When a delivery has happened, we will know it anyways due to Ukrainian attacks on targets which haven't been attacked before or due to previously unknown efficiency in combating various targets like storage places, factories and more.

2) That ends debates!
This assumption is also wrong. I don't know what makes people think that, but of course it won't end any debates. In my opinion, it could rather ensure that there are more debates.

On the one hand, I would like to point out once again that debates about the undisclosed military support from Germany were the reason why the military aid was made public in the first place. Merz and his CDU were also (rightfully) involved in early 2022.

On the other hand, that would mean that the people, the media and political opponents would muzzle themselves. Just because Merz decides not to respond to it anymore, news media X, Y, Z will decide to never write another article about German military aid? Or opposition politicians Müller, Meier, Schmitt won't talk about German aid anymore because of that? What kind of logic is that?

This decision will and should not end debates, regardless of what the new government claims.

3) We informed the Russians too much!
That could well be true. I agree. However, I would like to point out that even before the change of government (and also before the election in February), the old government had already switched from providing information about military aid once a week to every four or five weeks.

Four or five weeks is more than enough time to bring equipment to Ukraine and distribute it to the units. The Russians are aware of what is being deployed on the battlefield. It is also very likely that Russia will notice when a train with 20, 30 or 50 armoured vehicles arrives at the border, even without the German government's website.

I agree that too much information has been provided. In my opinion, it would be sufficient to provide limited information once a month. In other words, once a month, provide information with rough quantities about aid that already has been delivered. Also don't publicly announce new assistance anymore which hasn't been delivered yet.

That would be the golden path for me. For the most part, I just see disadvantages in the decision not to provide any more information at all.

Just as the previous transparency in combination with the help actually provided (and my work 😝) has ensured that Germany's image has continued to improve over time and is now considered a very reliable and of the best partners Ukraine has, this will now ensure that Germany's image will be damaged over time.

This also brings me to the next point. Transparency also helps to expose the “foul play” of other countries. I'm sure that the German transparency helped many people to realise how little France for example is actually doing for Ukraine in comparison, despite all the PR campaigns that Macron regularly launches.
18.05.202509:22
A backlog report from last week! During his visit to Lviv last Friday, Germany's new Foreign Minister, Johann Wadephul, announced that Germany would provide Ukraine with an additional €40 million in humanitarian aid.
Post media background
Post media
15.05.202509:57
Well, now it's official. The new German government just deleted their official list of military aid provided to Ukraine which it had maintained since mid-2022. The English version is still online, but I assume it will also be deleted in a few minutes.

As recently as Monday, a spokesperson for the German Ministry of Defence announced that the government would continue to announce what it supplies to Ukraine. However, details such as quantities will no longer be announced. Well...

I would like to take this opportunity once again to refer to my website, which is more comprehensive than the government website anyway 👇

English: deaidua.org/en/
German: deaidua.org
Post media background
Post media
15.05.202521:02
The German city of Delmenhorst is donating a decommissioned fire fighting vehicle from its fire brigade as well as a boat trailer including a hard-shell boat and a fire-fighting trailer which has a water cannon mounted on it to the Ukrainian city of Nikopol.

The equipment has already been handed over to the organisation O. K. Human Rights Ukraine, which is responsible for transporting it to Ukraine.

Image: Stadt Delmenhorst
17.05.202519:01
My latest piece → It remains to be seen whether Friedrich Merz will actually support Ukraine with more military aid than Olaf Scholz. First, however, he must honour commitments for 2025 that were made publicly by the previous German government.

Mein neuester Artikel → Es bleibt abzuwarten, ob Friedrich Merz die Ukraine tatsächlich mit mehr Militärhilfe unterstützen wird als Olaf Scholz. Zunächst muss er aber die von der Vorgängerregierung öffentlich gemachten Zusagen für 2025 einhalten.
06.05.202522:06
Germany's newly elected Chancellor Friedrich Merz has just now emphasised once again in a ZDF interview that he intends to provide Ukraine with Taurus KEPD-350 cruise missiles.

“President Zelenskyy knows that he can rely on me and on the Federal Republic of Germany.”
14.05.202510:31
In July 2022, Germany pledged six HEP 70 mobile decontamination vehicles including decontamination material from Bundeswehr stocks worth over €860,000 to Ukraine. After almost three years, I've now seen footage from Ukraine for the first time!

As always, I wanted to provide you with a full translation for the video. The decontamination systems are in service with the 704th CBRN Brigade of the Support Forces, which has shared this video three weeks ago.
Post media background
Post media
14.05.202507:53
Yesterday, UDI and Rheinmetall signed a new Memorandum of Cooperation on the possibility of establishing another joint venture in the field of artillery production in Ukraine.

Already in February 2024, both companies signed a first Memorandum of Understanding with the goal of establishing a joint venture for the production of artillery shells in Ukraine. The plan is to start operations in 2026 and produce significantly more than 150,000 155mm artillery shells per year.

Image: UDI
Post media background
Post media
28.04.202517:13
UPDATE 04/25 — Since we have almost reached the end of the month, I already wanted to provide you with the usual monthly infographic on German shell deliveries. After a weak past month, deliveries to Ukraine have picked up again with 1,000 122mm shells and 27,000 155mm shells.
12.05.202519:59
My latest piece → A spokesperson for the German MoD announced at today's government press conference that Germany will continue to provide information on arms deliveries to Ukraine. However, certain details will not be disclosed in the future.

Mein neuester Artikel → Ein Sprecher des deutschen Verteidigungsministeriums gab heute bekannt, dass Deutschland weiterhin Informationen über Waffenlieferungen an die Ukraine bereitstellen wird. Bestimmte Details werden aber künftig nicht mehr veröffentlicht.
14.05.202508:17
As part of a project of the German Society for International Cooperation (GIZ), which is funded by the German government, Teltow has provided its twin city Khotyn with a double-cab truck with a trailer, a scissor lift & battery-powered tools with a total value of ~ €55,000.

Images: Teltow
05.05.202519:09
My latest piece → According to a New York Times report, talks are underway concerning the delivery of another Patriot fire unit from Bundeswehr stocks to Ukraine. It could be possible, but it doesn't solve a fundamental problem of the Ukrainian army.

→ My article in English

Mein neuester Beitrag → Einem Bericht der New York Times zufolge laufen Gespräche über die Lieferung einer Patriot-Feuereinheit aus Bundeswehrbeständen an die Ukraine. Möglich, aber ein grundlegendes Problem der ukrainischen Armee bleibt bestehen.

→ Mein Artikel auf Deutsch
15.05.202511:05
More than two weeks ago, a larger column of at least 18 Cheetah SPAAGs without insignia was spotted by one of my followers in Eastern Germany. It can be assumed that the train was travelling eastwards to Ukraine.

Up to 60 Cheetah SPAAGs were bought back from Jordan by the US (up to 45) and Germany (15). However, the at least 18 SPAAGs visible in the images exceed the remaining pledges made by Germany, so in my opinion this should either be a mixed delivery (Germany & US) or a pure US delivery.

OPSEC disclaimer: I waited more than two full weeks before publishing the images to preserve OPSEC. This is more than enough time to bring the equipment to Ukraine, distribute it to the units and for them to be already using the equipment.

I also want to point out, that Gepard SPAAGs and Cheetah SPAAGs are being used far away from the front line to defend cities, military installations and critical infrastructure throughout the whole country. I'm also not going to share where in East Germany the images were taken.
10.05.202520:14
Just two addendums. Firstly, the “long-range artillery rockets” should be GMLRS with a range of up to 84 kilometres, as I wouldn't consider the German M26 (AT2) rockets “long-range”, as they “only” have a range of up to 38 kilometres.

Secondly, the delivery timeframe. As we are talking about existing Bundeswehr stocks and only about ammunition, we do not need to wait for the industry to produce them or a training to be carried out. A delivery to Ukraine should therefore be made within a few weeks.
Көбірек мүмкіндіктерді ашу үшін кіріңіз.